If You Knew Me

“If you really knew me… you wouldn’t like me.” “If you saw the real me… you wouldn’t love me.” Some of us have said something like that out loud. Many of us have heard it from someone we love. Most of us have at least heard it as a voice in our head… It’s the voice of shame. 

Shame takes a failure, a shortcoming, a mistake—even a sin—and turns into a verdict about our whole self. Shame hears us say, “I did something wrong,” and teaches us to say, “Something is fundamentally wrong with me.”

Society teaches us shame early in our lives. And once it takes root, it begins to shape the way we live. It has an uncanny power to isolate us, whispering that, if anyone saw who we really are, they’d turn away. It turns love into what essayist Tom Kreider once called “the mortifying ordeal of being known”—because love requires vulnerability—being seen as we are. And shame teaches us that being seen is dangerous. So we run and try to hide.

This shame-driven impulse to hide our true selves runs all the way back to the earliest chapters of the biblical story. After Adam and Eve eat the forbidden fruit in the Garden of Eden, their eyes are opened, they realise they’re naked, and they cover themselves. We heard that part of the story a couple of weeks ago. But the next moment in the story is even more revealing.

When they hear God walking in the garden at the time of the evening breeze, Adam and Eve are gripped by shame and fear and try to hide themselves among the trees. The scene is almost comical in its futility. They’re trying to run from the presence of the One who spoke the universe into existence, who fashioned their bodies and breathed life into them. You can run from God… but you can’t hide.

But the absurdity of the moment highlights the sad way shame distorts our lives and alienates us from ourselves, from each other, and from God. Seeing our sin—and feeling shame instead of repentance—we humans try to hide from the very source of our life. It’s as though we say to God, “Yeah, you made me. But if you really knew me… if you saw the real me… you couldn’t possibly love me.” Listening to shame, we mistake sinfulness for worthlessness. And suddenly, the idea that God sees and knows everything becomes a threat rather than a promise.

But the Gospel reading today shows us that it doesn’t have to be that way. In the story of Jesus and the Samaritan woman, we see what happens when shame meets grace. The woman at the well—called Photini in later tradition—knows a thing or two about the effects of shame. The Gospel never tells us directly how she feels about her situation or herself. But the setting of the story suggests that the social economy of shame has taken its toll.

For one thing, she’s a Samaritan, already stigmatised in the eyes of Jews. But the timing of her trip to the well is even more telling. She’s drawing water at noon. That’s the heat of the day—the worst possible time for this chore. Most women would have gone early in the morning or waited until the cool of the evening. Why is she there, in the middle of the day, alone?

We get a clue a few verses later: her irregular marital status. She’s had five husbands—more remarriages than religious norms permitted. And now she’s living with a man who isn’t her husband. In Photini’s world, that kind of history would have carried enormous stigma. It’s not hard to imagine the whispers of shame—in the voices of others, if not her own mind. So Photini goes to the well when no one else will be there. And there she encounters Jesus. 

Photini starts off kind of testy with Jesus. Alone in the middle of nowhere with a strange Jewish man asking for water? Her responses are understandably guarded at first. 

But the conversation unfolds. Jesus speaks of “living water”—water that quenches thirst forever—and Photini thaws a bit: “Sir, give me this water.” Her tone is polite but sceptical. Perhaps part of her is thinking, “He seems kind enough now. But if he really knew who I was… if he saw the real me…”

And then comes the turning point of her story: 

Jesus says, “Go, call your husband.” 

“I have no husband,” Photini replies.

And Jesus answers, “You’re right in saying you have no husband. For you have had five husbands, and the one you have now isn’t your husband.” 

In that moment, Jesus reveals that he knows the most intimate parts of Photini’s story. No shame. No scolding. No condemnation. He is simply naming the truth: “I do really know you. I do see the real you. I already know the story of your whole life, Photini.” This encounter with Jesus grabs her attention and changes everything. Instead of recoiling in shame—instead of running away—Photini runs toward her village. Instead of believing shame’s whispers—“If you really knew me, you wouldn’t love me”—Photini proclaims, “Come and see the man who told me everything I have ever done.”

That line gives me chills every time I read it: “Come and see the man who told me everything I have ever done.”

Under the influence of shame, the idea that someone could know everything about us is somewhere between unsettling and terrifying. “You can run, but you can’t hide.” But after encountering Jesus, that same reality becomes good news. “Come and see the man who told me everything I have ever done.”

What’s changed? Photini has learned that being fully known by Jesus doesn’t lead to rejection. It leads to deeper communion with the source of our life. It leads to living water that satisfies our souls. Jesus sees her as she truly is, and he doesn’t turn away. His gaze pierces even the shame-laden parts of her story and robs the shame of its power. The very thing Photini might once have hidden becomes her testimony that leads others to Christ: “Come and see.”

That is what encountering Jesus can do for us, too. It can transform the shame that alienates us from God, from others, and even from ourselves. And that matters especially in the season of Lent. Lent is an invitation to stop listening to shame—to stop running—to let ourselves be seen as we really are. Lent invites us to return to the well of living water—because the One we meet there isn’t waiting to condemn us. Jesus already knows the truth of our lives. His gaze reaches both the parts we are proud of and the parts that shame tells us to hide. And still, he doesn’t turn away from us. Still, he says, “Give me a drink” and offers us living water. Still, he invites us to encounter God more fully.

Shame tells us that being truly known is dangerous and wrong, but encountering Jesus with Photini at the well exposes shame’s insidious whispers as lies. The voice of shame says: “If you really knew me, you wouldn’t like me.” “If you saw the real me, you wouldn’t love me.” But in Christ, we learn that being fully known is part of being fully loved. And once we discover that… we no longer need to hide. Instead, we can say with Photini, “Come and see the man who told me everything I have ever done.” Because the One who knows the depths of our hearts is also the One who pours his love into our hearts, replacing shame with living water, gushing up to eternal life.