No Roadmap

The stories surrounding the Christmas narrative are so familiar to most of us that we can easily forget how dramatic the events really are. Take today’s gospel reading, for instance. We know the spiel, but pause and think about what is being asked of Joseph today. 

He’s being asked to take an entirely unknown path: to proceed with the engagement, take Mary as his wife, and claim her child as his own. He is being asked to do something that involves serious danger and risk for him, for Many, and for her unborn child. That risk is not hypothetical. Joseph and Mary are betrothed at this point, but they’re not fully married yet. In Jewish custom at the time, betrothal meant they were legally bound to each other, but they wouldn’t be fully married—they couldn’t consummate the marriage—until later. 

So if Joseph raises Mary’s child as his own, he risks being accused of ‘taking advantage’ of Mary (to put it mildly) and consummating the marriage before making an “honest woman” of her. In a cultural economy preoccupied with honor and shame, that would be social ruin for him. But if he divorces Mary and breaks off the betrothal—even if he does it as quietly as possible, as he plans—the risk for Mary is exponentially greater. At the very least, she risks being a social outcast, but she also faces the real possibility of being stoned for adultery. 

So this is a very high-stakes situation. Yet Joseph is being asked to take a leap of faith—to step into the unknown and play his part in salvation history.

As Christians today, we too are being asked to play out our part in salvation history, stepping into the unknown—without a roadmap of the future to guide us or the security of familiar experiences to reassure us. To be genuinely Christian—to be true disciples—is to place the Gospel at the center of everything we say and do—to imitate and proclaim God’s self-giving love with our whole lives. 

In today’s society, this kind of Christianity is a profoundly counter-cultural way of life. A Gospel truly animated by God’s incarnate love is deeply at odds with a world where human beings are treated as disposable—with a world that frames everything as a struggle between ‘us’ and ‘them’—with a world which teaches us to ‘mind our own business,’ hiding our light under a bushel and turning a blind eye to the pain, sorrow, and injustice in the world.  But a Gospel centered on the person of Jesus Christ treasures all human beings as precious creatures of God. It identifies with—loves—seeks the flourishing of—even our enemies. It propels us out into the world to proclaim God’s healing work far and wide. 

This is not a Gospel our world particularly wants to hear, but it is the Gospel that our world desperately needs. So the Church today can no longer be a mere social club or a private devotional society dedicated primarily to perpetuating the good old days, when resources were plentiful, and pews were full of children and families who were just expected to be there. That is not what the world needs. It needs a Gospel of transformative, self-giving love.

So, as Christians today—as people who are still being drawn by that love, to show up (somewhat explicably) in this place, with these people week after week—we are being asked to step out into the unknown—to live out and proclaim that Gospel in new ways, even when it brings no security or status; even when it actively invites ridicule and risk. 

Of course, the risk for us in this moment isn’t nearly as acute as it is for Mary and Joseph. We aren’t likely right now to be shunned or killed for saying yes to God’s call—for proclaiming a Gospel that truly challenges and transforms. But history shows us time and again that faithful discipleship can get that dangerous. So the risk is still real as we take a leap of faith. Like Joseph and Mary, we are still stepping into the unknown—into a realm where there is no blueprint or road map, where we are not in charge of our fates. These stakes are high enough that many have jumped ship, opting for an easier, softer way. Perhaps you’ve considered it. I know I have. It can be pretty damn daunting and discouraging to keep saying yes. 

But we aren’t the first ones to be daunted by not being in control. Nor are we the first to be given reassurance by God. Even as Joseph is daunted and wavering, he receives reassurance that, while he isn’t in control as he takes the leap of faith, God is. 

Notice that he isn’t promised that no harm will come to him, or Mary, or her unborn child. But he is promised that God will be there with them every step of the way as they play out their part in the divine drama of salvation history. And the reassurance isn’t just that God will be present in an abstract sense, as the concrete work of doing God’s will (and the risk that comes with it) falls on their shoulders. Mary and Joseph are both promised that God will be with them in the most radically tangible way possible as they play out their parts in the story of salvation. 

Mary and Joseph are promised that by playing their parts, they will be the means by which God truly becomes Emmanuel—God with us. They are assured that by saying ‘Yes’ to her impossibly dangerous mission, Mary will become the Mother of God. She will be that virgin bearing the Son promised by God to be the sign of hope and the redeemer of his people. They are assured that by adopting and raising Jesus as his own, Joseph will be raising that very shoot from Jesse’s tree, promised long ago as a sign to the nations, announcing in the midst of our helplessness that God is near at hand to rescue us. 

As they are asked to take this leap of faith, to step into the unknown with all the very real risks, Mary and Joseph are promised that God will be with them—that God is truly Emmanuel.

Two thousand years later, you and I receive that same reassurance, as we accept the risky mission of living out the Gospel in new, unknown, and sometimes scary ways. God doesn’t just assure us that he will be present with us in the abstract during this mission. United by baptism as the Body of Christ, we have been promised that by playing our part in the divine drama, we will become the means by which God is tangibly present in the world—the means by which God is proclaimed as Emmanuel—God with us—even now.

Like Mary and Joseph, we have crucial roles to play in salvation history. As the 13th-century mystic Meister Eckhart puts it, in imitation of the Blessed Virgin Mary, we are all called to be mothers of God in our own ways, bearing and bringing forth the promised Son of God in our hearts and in our lives. And by stepping into the unknown and patterning our lives on a counter-cultural Gospel, we not only imitate Joseph by raising a sign of salvation—we become that visible sign of God’s love in the world.

Like Mary and Joseph, we aren’t promised that God will preserve us from all harm as we step out into the unknown, neither guided by a clear blueprint nor in charge of our destiny. But we are promised that the God who is in charge is Emmanuel—God with us. We are promised that as we take up our mission of proclaiming the Gospel, we will always be inhabited by that Emmanuel—the Incarnate God who abides in us, as we abide in him.

So, to paraphrase the angel’s words to Joseph: Do not be afraid to say ‘yes’ and answer God’s call. Our God is and ever shall be Emmanuel—God with us.