Grievance Dependence Disorder

Grievance is a helluva drug.

I don’t mean just ‘being hurt.’ I mean holding onto it—ruminating on it—rehashing it. 

Our readings today underscore pretty emphatically how spiritually toxic that is. Not because every wrong is imagined. Often they’re very, very real. But because even when we are legitimately wronged, holding onto that grievance is a form of pride.

What do I mean by that?

In today’s Gospel, Jesus uses financial debt as a metaphor for sin—a breach in relationship, a failure to give someone their due. We shouldn’t take this metaphor too far, but it captures something Paul has been trying to get through our thick skulls for the past few weeks. As Christians, we do not live by ourselves or for ourselves. We live for the Lord, who died and rose for us. And that means we owe God our lives and we owe each other love. 

That debt is summed up in the greatest commandments: ‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, with all your mind, and with all your strength, and love your neighbor as yourself.’ So in today’s parable, Jesus uses a story of two servants’ debts to describe sin—when that ‘debt of love’ is not paid—when (as we confess at the beginning of mass) ‘we have not loved [God] with our whole hearts or our neighbors as ourselves.’

Importantly, neither debt in the parable presented is imaginary or fictitious.The first slave really does owe his master that money, and he is really owed money by his fellow slave. The problem isn’t that he wants that debt to be paid per se. The problem is that he treats the fellow slave in a way that totally ignores the fact he himself is a debtor too. In fact, this master of grievance is even more of a debtor! He’s owed 100 days’ wages by his fellow slave, but he himself owes somewhere around 54 million days’ wages.

And yet grievance blinds him to that fact. Fixating on the (real) debt owed him, he forgets that he owes an ever larger debt—larger to an absurd degree—to the one who is master of both of them. Grievance seems to make him forget about their master altogether. He forgets that, as Paul puts it, they both stand before the same judge. And so he puts himself in the place of that judge—their master. He judges his fellow slave harshly, disregarding—scorning—the forgiveness he’s just received from the real judge. 

This wicked slave in the parable receives a startling punishment for profaning the forgiveness he has received. And the narrative details of that punishment offend our modern sensibilities. But I think Jesus uses such sharp imagery, at least in part, to hammer home just how spiritually dangerous grievance is. Because holding grudges—ruminating on resentments—is extremely corrosive. Maybe we stew alone in our bed about how so-and-so offended us. Maybe we gather with our friends and whisper bitterly about such-and-such terrible people. But whatever it looks like, this kind of grievance is one of the most spiritually toxic poisons for communities and individuals alike.

There’s a reason that in 12 Step programs like AA, one of the first things we do is make a list of resentments that we need to work through and eventually let go of for the sake of our recovery—our survival. As long as we hold those resentments over others’ heads, we are ignoring the fact we are all fellow debtors who have received forgiveness from God for an infinitely greater debt than we could ever owe each other. And we take it upon ourselves to be master and judge, passing judgment on others for the ways they have wronged us.

When we usurp God’s judgment seat like that, we warp our relationships with God and each other. Eventually, even our relationship with ourselves can be warped. We start to lose touch with our humanity… with often disastrous consequences for ourselves, for our communities around us, and for those we drive out of our communities in the process. And grievance rarely takes up residence in our lives on its own. It’s a potent gateway drug and usually brings other dysfunction along with it.

Let me use myself as an example. As most of you know, I grew up in a very abusive environment that included things like forced conversion therapy (‘pray the gay away’) at age 13. I ended up needing to drop out of high school to escape. And grievance became my primary companion.

Don’t get me wrong. There was nothing ‘okay’ about what I was escaping. It wasn’t ‘fine.’ In the imagery of today’s parable, there was a real, unambiguous, and substantial debt that had not been paid. But I was not prepared to forgive that debt yet, and so I clung to my grievance, rehearsing over and over how I had been wronged—counting and recounting how much was owed to me.

Clinging to that grievance felt like righteous indignation. But as I held that bitter judgment over the heads of the people who had done those (again, legitimately terrible) things, I let grievance warp all of my other relationships. I lost sight of the fact that I, too, am a debtor—in different contexts and different ways—but I, too, have failed to render the love that I owe to God and my neighbor. And I lost sight of the fact that in the end, each of us will be accountable to God—that God has promised to set all things right in the fullness of time and that it isn’t down to me to mete out judgment and justice through the sheer force of a grudge.

I became addicted to these judgments I’d taken it upon myself to pass. And as that addiction alienated me from God and other people, it ultimately made me vulnerable to other diseases, poisons, and addictions—both spiritual and physical. Until my life became utterly unmanageable in a way that wouldn’t begin to change until years later when God led me (somewhat against my will) to the remedy to this illness—the antidote to this toxin of grievance.

But thank God there is an antidote.

My first sponsor summed it up with the line from the 90s movie Rudy: ‘There is a God, and I’m not him.’ But we also hear Joseph capture it well in our first reading today. He’s responding to his brothers’ pleading for mercy for beating him and selling him into slavery. (Talk about legitimate grounds for grievance.) But rather than holding his brothers’ debt against them, Joseph weeps and says, ‘Do not be afraid! Am I in the place of God?’

‘Am I in the place of God?’

Joseph is embodying the opposite of Grievance Dependence Disorder here. But note that he never says, ‘It’s fine. It’s no big deal. Forget about it.’ What his brothers did WASN’T fine, and he doesn’t skirt around the fact that they wronged him grievously. But rather than hanging on to that grievance and holding it over their heads, Joseph says, ‘Do not fear. Am I in the place of God? Even though you intended to do harm to me, God intended it for good.’

Joseph addresses the wrongdoing head-on. But he also remembers that God is God and he is not. It is not his job to pass final judgment or to nurse a grudge until justice is served. Joseph remembers that he too is a servant of God—a servant who has been forgiven a debt ultimately just as great as his brothers. And so, without glossing over the grievous harm done to him, Joseph is able to live out and extend the only antidote to this potent drug of grievance: forgiving as we ourselves have been forgiven. 

This forgiveness isn’t a matter of our own willpower. What actually breaks grievance's hold on us is the same thing that breaks any addiction's hold: remembering who and whose we are. That's what Joseph is remembering when he asks his brothers, ‘Am I in the place of God?’ That remembering is the antidote to grievance and the path to forgiveness. Not forgetting or ignoring the wrong. But remembering that none of us occupies the judgment seat—that we are all debtors first, not living for ourselves but for the merciful God in whom we live and move and have our being. 

So the next time grievance offers you the fleeting high of bitterness—(and believe me, it will, because grievance always comes back around, craving to be fed)—remember who and whose you are. Remember your own debt of love that has already been forgiven. And let that remembrance of God’s grace loosen grievance's grip on your soul and move you to forgive as you have been forgiven.