We have a decision to make, you and I.
A choice—here and now.
It’s the same decision faced by the religious leaders in today’s Gospel. They’ve cornered Jesus in the Jerusalem Temple and demand to know what authority he teaches by. For others this might be a legitimate curiosity. But these leaders aren’t asking because they want to know. They’re trying to trip Jesus up—to get him to claim, publicly, with witnesses, the divine authority we hear him claim elsewhere in the Gospels: that he speaks the words of the Father, by whom he was sent, with whom he is one. If they can get him to say that out loud, here and now, they can discredit him. Maybe even eliminate him.
But in a classic teacher’s move, Jesus turns the question back on them: ‘What about John’s baptism? Where did that come from? Heaven? Or was it of human origin?’ Now they’re the ones backed into the corner. Think about what a dilemma this is for them: If they say John’s authority came from heaven, they condemned themselves—because they never believed him, never submitted to his baptism, even though they knew, at some level, that God was speaking through him.
But if they say that John only taught with human authority, they risk pissing off the crowd, who have already decided that John was a true prophet. Neither of these choices lead to ideal outcomes. So what do they do instead? They evade the question and choose not to choose. ‘We don’t know,’ they say. They refuse to decide and declare what they believe.
They aren’t rejecting outright the possibility that God might speak to them. After all, God sent prophets like Ezekiel many times to speak to his chosen people. And these guys would tell you without hesitation that they’re definitely among God’s chosen. But when it comes time to decide whether they’ll actually heed the voice of God calling them here and now, they choose to sit on the fence instead.
We get a rare glimpse into their reasoning here, and it is somewhat specific to their situation. They’re worried about their political position. But underneath their particular motivations is a trap we’re all susceptible to—as individuals and as communities—the refusal to choose whether to accept God’s call or reject it. And the temptation to dress that refusal up as caution, or nuance, or humility.
What does that choice—or that refusal to choose—look like among us?
It looks like paying lip service to sacrificial discipleship while rarely, if ever, actually getting up from the pew to live it out ourselves. It looks like calling ourselves Christian but declining the responsibility—and the accountability to others—that comes with the title. It looks like saying we want to be a church while shying away from what belonging to Christ’s Body on earth actually costs us. It looks like professing to be a visible sign of God’s love while quietly (or not so quietly) resisting the radical conversion and change that that love requires.
Basically, it looks like the son in the parable who says, ‘I go, sir,’ but then doesn’t actually go.
That’s one way to answer Jesus’ question: refusal to choose whether we’ll acknowledge God’s claim on our lives or not.
But there’s another way—the way of the other son in the parable—the one who says no at first, but in the end, goes anyway.
This way looks like decisively choosing to answer God’s call and follow through, even when we don’t especially want to. It looks like earnestly heeding Christ’ call to repent from our sinful preoccupation with self and be healed, transformed and turned outward. It looks like accepting the new heart, the new spirit, that Jesus offers and choosing, day after day, to continue the journey of being remade in his likeness, until his ‘mind’—his way of seeing, his way of living and loving—becomes our own. It looks like rolling up our sleeves and actually doing the work of discipleship and service for the sake of all, rather than merely admiring it from a distance or only living it out for those we particularly like.
In other words, it looks like deciding and declaring: ‘Yes, Jesus Christ is Lord. He speaks and acts with the authority of God. And we choose to live accordingly.’
This choice isn’t an optional extra for some spiritual elite within the Church. This choice is the very substance of what it means to be Christian. It’s the choice put before us on the day we are baptized, when we renounce evil and turn to Christ, who marks us as his own forever and promises us an inheritance with him. And it’s the choice we face every day after that—the same question, asked again and again: Will we hem and haw like the chief priests and elders, weighing whether God’s call is worth the trouble? Or will we choose, day after day, to work out the salvation we’ve already been promised?
‘Choosing that every day is a pretty tall order, Father,’ you might say, ‘I don’t know it’s possible.’
It sure ain’t.
Not for us on our own, at least. Speaking for myself based on my own track record, I can say pretty confidently that, left to my own devices, I wouldn’t even have the desire to be Christ’s disciple—let alone the strength to decide to actually follow him, day after day. But even as Paul tells the Philippians today to work out their salvation with fear and trembling, he points past our own willpower to the foundation of this whole Christianity thing: ‘It is God who is at work in you, enabling you both to will and to work for his good pleasure.’
To will and to work. To desire and to decide. Neither one is ours to conjure ourselves. Both are gifts offered if we will just accept them.
Yes, we still have to choose whether we will answer the call to truly follow Christ. God won’t stop putting that choice before us, again and again. And what we choose has real, even eternal consequences. But far from leaving us alone in the face of that daunting dilemma, God freely offers us the fullness of grace. And it’s by receiving that grace, and letting it work in us, that we come to desire the treasure stored up for us and find ourselves able, at last, to decide to run and obtain it.
So today, on this my last Sunday with you—let me leave you with the Apostle’s own charge: Not only in my presence, but now, so much more, in my absence, work out your salvation with fear and trembling. For it is God who is at work in you, enabling you both to will and to work for his good pleasure—if you choose to let him.